Survey: 60% of Consumers Would Switch Stores After Unexpected Closure
New Hanover Insurance research finds customer loyalty has clear limits when small businesses face unplanned disruptions.
A majority of American consumers would take their business to a competitor if a favorite small business closed unexpectedly, according to new research released by The Hanover Insurance Group and Statista. The findings, published in The Hanover's 2026 Small Business Pulse Report, place fresh pressure on small business owners to invest in continuity planning and risk preparedness.
The survey found that 60% of respondents said they would shop with a competing business during an unplanned closure, underscoring how quickly consumer habits can shift when a preferred vendor is unavailable. The data signals that brand loyalty, while valuable, offers limited protection against the operational and financial fallout of unexpected disruptions.
Read more Huawei Showcases AI Scaling Tools for Finance at Singapore FinTech Fest →
Beyond customer retention, the report also examines broader themes shaping the small business landscape, including consumer expectations around trust and employee safety. Researchers say these findings reflect a post-pandemic shift in which customers have grown accustomed to alternative options and are less inclined to wait for a business to reopen.
For small business owners, the report serves as a reminder that continuity planning is not solely an internal operational concern — it directly affects customer relationships and long-term revenue. Experts in the insurance and risk management sectors have long argued that business interruption coverage and documented recovery plans are essential tools, particularly for independently owned enterprises with limited financial reserves.
The Hanover Insurance Group, traded on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker THG, partnered with research firm Statista to conduct the survey. Continue reading at Banking & Financial Services.